• >
  • Loans>
  • Guides>
  • Should you get an overdraft, credit card or loan?

Should you get a credit card, loan or overdraft?

Choosing the right way to borrow money can make it cheaper and easier to manage. Here is when you should use a credit card, loan or overdraft.

Share this guide

Think carefully before securing other debts against your home. You home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage or any other debt secured on it.

What’s the difference between a credit card, loan and overdraft?

Credit cards, loans and overdrafts are all ways to borrow money, but they each work in slightly different ways.

Credit Card: A credit card lets you borrow money and pay it off over time. Credit cards are generally meant for short-term borrowing in amounts ranging between £1,000 and £5,000. 

They’re good for making small purchases, or spreading the cost of larger purchases over time. Each time you buy something, the lender pays for the item and then sends you a monthly bill. It will also apply interest, which you will pay as a percentage of the amount you borrow. 

Loan: A loan is when you borrow a fixed lump sum of money. It has to be repaid over a set period of time through fixed monthly instalments.

Overdraft: An overdraft lets you borrow money from your bank by allowing you to have a negative bank balance. You may pay a monthly or daily interest rate for using it. 

What to consider when choosing between a credit card, loan or overdraft

How much do you need to borrow?

How much you need to borrow will be a key factor in your decision on whether to choose a credit card, loan, or overdraft

Credit Card: Credit cards are generally meant for short-term borrowing, in amounts ranging between £1,000 and £5,000. However, sometimes credit limits can go up to £10,000 and above. 

Loan: There are several different types of loans that let you borrow differing amounts. Personal loans, for example, are typically meant for borrowing large sums of money, ranging from £5,000 to £25,000. With homeowner loans – a type of secured loan – you can borrow much more, although your home could be repossessed if you can’t make the repayments.

Overdraft: You can usually borrow up to £1,000 with an arranged overdraft, although you can borrow more if you have a high income and a great credit history. These are useful if you have occasional cash flow problems. They’re a short-term option and should really only be used as an emergency back-up, to borrow a small amount of money for a short period. 

How quickly do you need the money?

The speed at which you need access to cash will play a vital part in which credit product you choose.

Credit Card: The time between applying for a credit card and receiving it in the post can be anywhere between seven days and two weeks. So, if you need the money quickly, a credit card might not be the best option.

Loans: Funds are typically approved within 24 hours, so this can help if you need to get your hands on cash in a hurry.

Overdraft: An overdraft with your bank can generally be set up in a matter of a few hours. This makes an overdraft a good choice in an emergency, such as an unexpected cash flow problem.

With any type of borrowing, if you have bad credit or the lender thinks you may be unable to afford the borrowing, your application could take longer as it may need to carry out extra checks. Often you will be asked to send extra information if this is the case. 

How long do you need to pay the money back?

The amount of time to repay a debt will depend on the type of credit card, loan or overdraft you choose. 

  • Credit cards usually ask you to pay back a minimum payment each month but have no set end date. Any 0% deals on purchases and balance transfers you get will only last a set number of months, agreed at the time you take the card out

  • Loans can normally be repaid over one and seven years, making them better for longer term borrowing

  • Overdrafts have no set repayment date. However, they can be withdrawn at any time by your bank. Plus, any interest-free period you’re given may only last a set period, such as a year.

What are the pros and cons of credit cards, loans and overdrafts?

Credit card

Pros

  • You can access the cash quickly
  • If you need to borrow more money a loan is better than other methods
  • Repayments are fixed so you know exactly how much you’ll pay
  • Interest rates are competitive if you have a good credit score

Cons

  • Interest added to balance monthly
  • Takes over a week to access the money
  • Credit limit not set until you apply
  • Withdrawing cash is very expensive
  • Only making the minimum payment can cost you more

Loan

Pros

  • You can access the cash quickly
  • If you need to borrow more money a loan is better than other methods
  • Repayments are fixed so you know exactly how much you’ll pay
  • Interest rates are competitive if you have a good credit score

Cons

  • Some loans require security
  • Less flexible repayments
  • Charges to pay back early

Overdraft

Pros

  • Easy to withdraw cash
  • Can be quick to access cash
  • Flexible borrowing
  • Good for occasional short term borrowing

Cons

  • It tends to be used for smaller amounts
  • The interest rates and fees can be high
  • The interest is added to the balance monthly
  • Your overdraft can be cancelled at any time
  • It’s not good for regular or long-term borrowing

Getting the best deal on a credit card, loan or overdraft

Whether you decide to go for a credit card, loan or overdraft you need to shop around to get the best deal. Costs can vary substantially among all three.

If you choose a credit card

You need to pick a card that suits how you want to borrow money:

Here’s how to get accepted for a credit card.

If you choose a loan

You need to look for a loan that:

  • Lets you borrow the amount of money you need

  • Gives you long enough to pay it back with payments you can afford

  • Offers the cheapest interest rate.

Here’s how to get accepted for a loan.

If you choose an overdraft

You need to look for an overdraft that’ll cost the least amount of money and suits the way you will use it.

What’s an overdraft?

What could I use a credit card, loan or overdraft for?

As a general rule, you should remember that:

  • Overdrafts are for short-term borrowing for unforeseen emergencies

  • Credit cards are for short-term borrowing and can be used to spread the cost of purchases

  • Loans are for borrowing larger amounts of money for a specific purchase reason such as a car or holiday.

Some of the common reasons to borrow money are listed below, with the suitable types of borrowing.

  • Buying a car: loan, credit card (depending on the vehicle price)

  • Paying for your wedding: loan, credit card

  • A holiday: loan, credit card

  • Home improvements: loan

  • Replacing expensive appliances: loan, credit card

  • Debt consolidation: loan, credit card

  • Vehicle repairs: loan, credit card, overdraft

  • Unexpected bills: credit card, overdraft.

Compare loans

Need a loan? Compare loan lenders side by side to find one that is cheap to pay back, lets you borrow what you need and has repayments you can afford.